Elementary students press Philly mayoral candidates on playgrounds, arts, guns


What civic issues press on the minds of the city’s fourth- and fifth-graders?


The two top mayoral candidates got a chance to find out Tuesday at an event held at Philadelphia School District headquarters and hosted by the Rendell Center for Civics and Civic Engagement.

Some of the fourth-grade class at Isaac Sheppard Elementary in West Kensington reminded Democrat Jim Kenney and Republican Melissa Murray Bailey on the need for more extracurriculars in schools.

  • WHYY thanks our sponsors — become a WHYY sponsor

Fourth-grader Abdul Luna read a letter he wrote to the candidates.

“We could really benefit from art, music, gym, sports, recess games and many more things too,” said Abdul. “First, I think we should have these things because it will make our students more social and active with each other.”

Murray Bailey pledged to the children that she’d return needed resources to schools, no matter action at the state level.

“It’s really important that we invest in those, and that means sometimes we’re not going to be able to do other things that we used to do in the city,” she said. “But it’s really important to fund the schools, because if we don’t do that, then you guys aren’t going to be able to reach the potential that I know you can.”

In addition to working to secure additional education funds from Harrisburg, Kenney said he’d lease the mayor’s luxury box suites at Citizens Bank Park, Lincoln Financial Field and Wells Fargo Center.

“We’re going to lease those boxes out, and we’re going to take that money and give it to that nonprofit so we can supplement school activities,” he said.

Kenny’s campaign anticipates generating $1 million annually from these leases.

From Fern Rock, Julia Ward Howe Elementary fourth-grader Diamond Novill wondered what the candidates would do about gun violence.

“I had a family member hurt by guns. I think the next mayor should ban guns in the city, and the world,” she said. “Guns hurt too many people. It affects me a lot. It makes me sad. I think if there were strict gun laws then people would not do as much crime.”

Kenney gave this response:

“Let me give you a really cold and cruel fact of life, and I hate to do this, but I have to do it. We can’t control guns in Philadelphia, because Harrisburg refuses to control guns in Pennsylvania,” he said. “People in Harrisburg vote continuously to keep us from having the ability to control guns, control straw purchases and to control people who use guns in the wrong way.”

Murray Bailey tied the gun issue with her aim to connect the city’s teenagers with job-training programs.

“I think the jobs is the really key piece to that, because most people really are good people, and by not having the things they need, it causes them to do things that they shouldn’t be doing,” she said.

The students engaged the candidates on other topics including neighborhood safety – urging more police officers – and about the need for the city to address some unsafe playground conditions in their communities.

Afterward, former Gov. Ed Rendell, whose group organized the event, spoke about the importance of engaging students in civics early.

“People said, ‘Oh, you shouldn’t do elementary school. Do high school.’ High school’s too late,” said Rendell. “We need to imbue these kids with what their rights and responsibilities under the Constitution, under our laws are, and these kids are smart.”

Candidates weigh in on latest district proposals

District Superintendent William Hite recently recommended a slate of moves that would affect 15 schools and 5,000 students – proposed changes that include new school openings, closings and district-led and charter conversions.

Thus far, the most robust debate has centered on Hite’s plan to convert three chronically underperforming elementary schools into neighborhood-based charters: Jay Cooke Elementary in Logan, Samuel Huey Elementary in West Philly and John Wister Elementary in Germantown.

Some parents at the schools have pushed back hard on the proposals, and many have criticized the district for making parents jump through hoops in order to attend community meetings on the issue.

After the Rendell Center event, Kenney and Murray Bailey offered thoughts on the matter.

Kenney said he was against all charter expansion until the state reinstates the funding, cut under Gov. Tom Corbett, that used to help traditional school districts defray some of the added systemic costs of charter schools.

“You can’t starve schools of resources and then complain they don’t work, which is what I believe this whole intention was in the first place …” said Kenney. “Give us back the money we’re losing, and then we can have a competent discussion.”

The district has argued that – as all schools have grappled with austerity budgeting in the past few years – it tapped schools for conversion that have fared worse than their peers.

Murray Bailey praised Hite’s plan.

“I’d like to see the parents more actively involved in that process; however, when you look at the other renaissance charters, the numbers don’t lie. The kids are reading better than they were before,” she said. “I don’t think it’s public or charter, I think we need to give kids a great opportunity, and stop telling parents that they have to wait.”

Taken as a cohort, the district’s 20 charter conversions – known as “renaissance charters” – have evidenced gains in academics and school culture.

But some of the schools have fallen well short of expectations.

The district is seeking non-renewal of its contract with Universal Bluford, a renaissance charter elementary school converted in 2010.

The district was set to seek non-renewal for Young Scholars Frederick Douglass, converted in 2010, before agreeing to allow Mastery Charter Schools to take over at the beginning of this school year.

Over the summer, the management of Birney Elementary – a school near Cooke Elementary that was converted in 2011 – was quietly transferred from Mosaica to American Paradigm.

In 2014, the district lobbied for Aspira to take over operations at Munoz-Marin. Since then, the district has chided Aspira – which runs renaissance conversions at Stetson middle school and Olney High School – for its fiscal and management practices.

WHYY is your source for fact-based, in-depth journalism and information. As a nonprofit organization, we rely on financial support from readers like you. Please give today.

Want a digest of WHYY’s programs, events & stories? Sign up for our weekly newsletter.

Together we can reach 100% of WHYY’s fiscal year goal