Over $1 billion meant for NJ clean energy fund diverted for other uses

(Image from ©New Jersey Board of Public Utilities' Clean Energy Program brochure)

(Image from ©New Jersey Board of Public Utilities' Clean Energy Program brochure)

Even though more than $1 billion has been diverted from a New Jersey clean-energy fund, a top Christie administration official yesterday defended the state’s efforts to reduce energy use and cut emissions contributing to global warming.

In an appearance before the state Senate Budget and Appropriations Committee, Board of Public Utilities President Richard Mroz faced questions over the $1.3 billion — including $121 million next year — taken from utility customers to balance state budgets during the Christie administration.

The diversion of the funds has been repeatedly criticized by clean-energy advocates who believe it is adversely affecting the state’s efforts to switch to less-polluting methods of generating electricity like solar systems and invest in ways to reduce energy consumption.

Some lawmakers also fault the practice, initiated by the Jon Corzine administration, but the Legislature has gone along with the governors and approved the diversions in every budget since the 2008 fiscal year.

  • WHYY thanks our sponsors — become a WHYY sponsor

In next year’s budget plan, the governor proposes to use $114.5 million from the fund to pay for energy costs at state buildings and for NJ Transit. Another $3.7 million from the clean-energy fund would go to the state Department of Environmental Protection’s office of green energy and to pay for administrative costs at the BPU’s office of clean energy.

Mroz noted that the money being diverted in next year’s proposed spending plan is virtually identical to what lawmakers approved in the current state budget. The fund is supported by a surcharge on utility customer’s bills, which amounted to at most to $56.67 annually for the average electrical user and $89.10 for the average gas user, according to an analysis by the Office of Legislative Services.

The cost is much higher for the typical industrial customer because the surcharge is based on how energy is used.

Sen. Linda Greenstein (D-Mercer) questioned whether the continued diversions are impeding efforts to cut energy use, noting New Jersey has dropped in an often-cited ranking by an energy-efficiency association from being rated in the top 10 nationally to 23rd.

“New Jersey has and continues to have a robust energy-efficiency program that is meeting our needs and reducing emissions,’’ Mroz told the committee, when asked about the diversions. Over the past 15 years, the state has invested more than $2..4 billion in energy efficiency, Mroz said.

Mroz also said New Jersey does not need an energy-efficiency portfolio standard, a policy adopted by other states to require a specified reduction in energy use. “We don’t feel that setting that goal is necessary,’’ he said.

Next year, the BPU is planning to allocate $344 million for its clean-energy program, but typically does not spend all of the money it has set aside, a practice that has made the fund more inviting to be tapped when the state is facing a budget crisis.

As for the state’s prospects for developing offshore wind farms, Mroz was less optimistic. The state’s Energy Master Plan recommends 1,100 megawatts of offshore wind be developed by 2020, a target impossible to achieve at this point. Critics blame the BPU for failing to write crucial regulations to help finance the projects with ratepayer subsidies.

Mroz acknowledged two developers have leased acreage offshore to build wind turbines, but was noncommittal about moving forward quickly. “It depends on what is presented by the developers and what the costs are,’’ he said. Studies to answer those questions and others could take a year or more.


NJ Spotlight, an independent online news service on issues critical to New Jersey, makes its in-depth reporting available to NewsWorks.

WHYY is your source for fact-based, in-depth journalism and information. As a nonprofit organization, we rely on financial support from readers like you. Please give today.

Want a digest of WHYY’s programs, events & stories? Sign up for our weekly newsletter.

Together we can reach 100% of WHYY’s fiscal year goal