Watson Coleman win sets stage for New Jersey’s first black Congresswoman

 (Bonnie Watson Coleman (right). (Photo courtesy of NJ Spotlight)

(Bonnie Watson Coleman (right). (Photo courtesy of NJ Spotlight)

Yesterday’s primary all but guaranteed that New Jersey will have its first female Congressional representative in more than a decade, and first black woman ever, with Assemblywoman Bonnie Watson Coleman’s win in the 12th District Democratic primary.

In the 1st Congressional District, Camden-area voters took the first step toward choosing their first new representative since 1990, and in the 3rd Congressional District, Burlington and Ocean county Republicans picked the more moderate of two GOP candidates to replace retiring Republican Congressman Jon Runyan in a district that two national political reports say Democrats have a chance of winning in November.

In the race for U.S. Senate, Republican voters chose the man who in a 1978 primary ousted N.J.’s last elected GOP Senator, but went on to lose the general election. He now faces an uphill battle to try to unseat Democratric Senator Cory Booker in November.

Unofficial election returns show turnout was very low across most of the state as generally Democrats and Republicans alike sat out the mostly ho-hum contests for the nominations for the Senate and a dozen seats in the House of Representative. About 12 percent of Democrats statewide went to the polls, and about 15 percent of Republicans, county turnout figures show. (Detailed results of primaries across the state are available online.)

  • WHYY thanks our sponsors — become a WHYY sponsor

U.S. Senate

Although the U.S. Senate race would normally draw the most attention, it was virtually ignored this year because Booker was unopposed on the ballot and the four Republicans vying for the GOP nomination were mostly unknown, underfunded, and quiet. There’s also a feeling that the Republican Senate primary results may be anticlimactic, due to Booker’s popularity and the fact that New Jersey has not elected a Republican to the U.S. Senate since 1972.

The GOP Senate race proved to be close, with no candidate dominating. Jeff Bell, who beat Sen. Clifford Case in the 1978 Senate primary, only to lose to Bill Bradley in the fall, appeared to have won less than 30 percent of the votes cast. Bell had nearly 42,000 votes, compared with about 37,000 for Richard Pezzullo, who was in second with about 26 percent. Roughly 40 precincts were still uncounted as of midnight, leading Pezzullo, a technology consultant who has never held elective office, to delay conceding. Most recently policy director with a national conservative organization, Bell had spent the most on the race as of May 14 — $86,000, meager by today’s standards. Pezzullo reported spending less than $2,000.

Rich Danker, Bell’s campaign manager, attributed Bell’s win to his having suggested a solution to the nation’s economic distress — returning to the gold standard. Despite what all the pundits say, Bell is confident he can best Booker in November.

“He wouldn’t have gotten into this race if he didn’t think he could beat Cory Booker,” said Danker. “Look, Cory Booker didn’t win by that much in his special election last year and he didn’t do a very good job running Newark, that’s for sure. So we feel like he’s very vulnerable as an incumbent and we’re excited to be able to advance now and take him on in a statewide race in a year where Republicans look very fortunate in running against what has turned out to be a terrible economy. It’s a really bad environment to be a Democrat in.”

12th Congressional District

The most exciting of the House races was the one in the 12th District in Central Jersey, which ranges from Union County through Somerset and Middlesex down to Mercer and includes Trenton and Princeton. What was expected to be a close race between Assemblywoman Bonnie Watson Coleman (D-Mercer) and Sen. Linda Greenstein (D-Middlesex), turned out not to be. Ultimately, Watson Coleman’s home county of Mercer, as well as Plainfield in Union County, came out strong to help her win in the four-candidate field with nearly 43 percent of the vote. With nearly all precincts reporting, Watson Coleman had 15,413 votes, a 5,000-vote lead over Greenstein.

All night, the mood in Watson Coleman’s election night headquarters at the Lafayette Yards Hotel in Trenton was positive, buoyed by an upbeat disc jockey. By 10 p.m., it was rocking. On hand were dozens of families and friends, many talking about “Bonnie” with the familiarity of a cousin or neighbor. As the night moved on, a few fellow Democratic colleagues also filtered in, many from Trenton and elsewhere in Mercer County.

Greenstein’s party took the opposite trajectory. At 9 p.m., the turnout at the IBEW 456 union hall in North Brunswick was healthy, with senior citizens who were the core of the state Senator’s support making an especially a strong showing. But as the voting results started to come in, the friendly chatter hushed to make time for twitter scrolling and poll refreshing, and the mood switched to quiet, then anxious, then somber. By 10 p.m., the crowd was starting to thin.

Watson Coleman eventually declared victory a little before 11 p.m., walking into a jovial and dancing crowd. As she stepped to the podium, retiring Democrat Rep. Rush Holt joined her, as did state Sen. Shirley Turner (D-Mercer) and Mercer County Executive Brian Hughes. She praised her team and supporters, including those from her native Trenton.

“My hometown showed up,” she declared to a cheering crowd.

Greenstein won Middlesex County by nearly 6,000 votes, but it appeared to have the lightest turnout of the four counties in the district — 11 percent, compared to 20 percent in Mercer. Watson Coleman beat Greenstein in Mercer by 8,000 votes .

A beaming Watson Coleman called her opponents “all honorable people, all people who believe in the things we believe in. That’s the message I want to tell Democrats — we are united front, we are different from Republicans.”

She listed her priorities for Congress — immigration reform, women’s rights, gun control and public education — before saying that there was much work first to do to win the general election.

“This is just the first step, and we have a big step to take in November,” she said.

Holt praised her and her supporters. “We are not just making progress, we are making history,” the outgoing congressman said. “She has endless energy, a compassion heart, and she has smarts.”

Greenstein was far more subdued.

“One of the things you never know is how you are going to react,” she said in her concession speech. “I haven’t cried yet and then I look around the room and I see all of the people who have been so helpful and so supportive of me . . . I am still a woman in the (state) Senate.”

Supporters said Greenstein made a valiant fight. Assemblywoman Nancy Pinkin told the crowd, “We had four great candidates that all ran great campaigns and it doesn’t always turn out the way you hoped but now we will get behind Watson Coleman and hopefully we are one step closer to having a woman representing us in Congress.” 

3rd Congressional District

Although the 3rd District Republican campaign started as a horse race, former Randolph Mayor Tom MacArthur quickly pulled ahead of former Bogota Mayor and multiple also-ran Steve Lonegan. MacArthur pumped $2 million of his own money into his campaign and he gained the endorsement of the Burlington and Ocean Republican parties. Lonegan had touted his win in the district in last year’s U.S. Senate campaign and had hoped his conservative message would win the day, but he won only 40 percent of the vote.In his prepared victory speech, MacArthur pledged to gather a coalition of voters of both parties and the unaffiliated as he seeks to replace Republican Rep. Jon Runyan, retiring after just two terms in office.

“In the campaign ahead, I intend to emulate Ronald Reagan, and articulate a positive, optimistic message built around common sense conservative principles of individual responsibility and freedom, smaller government and free markets — while extending a compassionate hand-up to hardworking people who are struggling every day to build a better life for themselves and their families,” he said.

Two national political reports had labeled this district as a toss-up in November, both because the seat is open and because Democrats slightly outnumber Republicans. It has vacillated between the parties for the last 50 years. MacArthur will face Burlington County Freeholder Aimee Belgard, who won easily with 83 percent over two opponents.

1st Congressional District

A third seat was open, in the 1st District that encompasses Camden and its environs. Democrat Rob Andrews resigned in February, so the seat is currently vacant. State Sen. Donald Norcross (D-Camden) easily won the Democratic primary, as expected, over two challengers. Norcross won nearly three quarters of the votes. He will face former professional football player, Garry Cobb, who beat three other GOP hopefuls. But with the district heavily Democratic, Norcross is expected to cruise to victory in November. He also won the nomination to fill Andrews’ unexpired term from November through January and is a shoo-in, since no Republicans filed.

Norcross said last night that he was humbled by the victory and, if elected in November, pledged to “fight to change the culture of obstruction and extreme partisanship in Washington that is blocking meaningful progress on many critical issues.” He also promised to work for South Jersey issues, including an expansion of light rail, strengthening the Delaware River port, and getting research and development grants for South Jersey’s college.

Other races

There were no surprises in the results. All the incumbents on the ballot won renomination and the expected challengers won their bids:

In the 2nd in South Jersey, Rep. Frank LoBiondo won with more than 82 percent over GOP challenger Mike Assad, while Bill Hughes, son of the former congressman, bested his Democratic opponent David Cole by nearly the same margin.

In the northernmost 5th District, Roy Cho got 90 percent of the vote over Diane Sare and will face GOP Rep. Scott Garrett.

For the third election in a row, Rep. Leonard Lance beat David Larsen in the 7th District GOP primary and will face Democrat Janice Kovach.

In the 10th District that includes parts of Newark and Jersey City, freshman Rep. Donald M. Payne Jr. faced three opponents and still won more than 90 percent of the vote. He will face Republican Yolanda Dentley in the fall.

In the 11th District in North Jersey, Rep. Rodney P. Frelinghuysen got two thirds of the Republican votes to beat opponent Rick Van Glahn and will face Democratic winner, Marc Dunec, who finished first in a field of three with 76 percent.


John Mooney, Selena Handler, and Chase Brush contributed to this story. NJ Spotlight, an independent online news service on issues critical to New Jersey, makes its in-depth reporting available to NewsWorks.

Want a digest of WHYY’s programs, events & stories? Sign up for our weekly newsletter.

Together we can reach 100% of WHYY’s fiscal year goal