Philadelphia sues state to reduce youth justice overcrowding
In the lawsuit filed Friday, city officials said there were 223 youths at the facility designed to temporarily hold 184.
The City of Philadelphia is asking a judge to force Pennsylvania’s Department of Human Services to take custody of more than 70 juveniles sentenced in court to state rehabilitation programs, hoping to alleviate what it says is dangerous overcrowding at the city’s holding facility.
In the lawsuit filed Friday, city attorneys said the state has refused to prioritize transferring juveniles from the overcrowded facility.
Workers from Philadelphia’s juvenile facility spoke last week at a City Council hearing about worsening conditions at the facility that’s designed to temporarily hold up to 184 youths between the ages of 10 and 17 who are awaiting court proceedings. But as of last Friday the lawsuit said the facility had reached 223 juveniles— 74 of whom had been sentenced to state facilities and were awaiting transfer.
A spokeswoman for the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services did not immediately respond to emails seeking comment Monday. The department has previously said the state’s facilities are at capacity for their staffing levels, which are also down.
Staff at the facility said more than 20 juveniles are currently sleeping on mattresses on the floor in the admissions portion of the facility, which is not designed to house them. They also said the increased population combined with a staffing shortage has meant children have not been able to leave their cells or housing areas for school, for meals or for recreational time because moving them around the facility has become dangerous.
“For too long, the Commonwealth has been derelict in this fundamental duty. The City, in good faith, pleaded with state officials to fulfill their obligations and avoid the crisis we are now seeing,” Vanessa Garrett Harley, Philadelphia’s deputy mayor for the Office of Children and Families said in an emailed statement Monday. “As months passed, unfortunately, no meaningful action was taken on their part and empty promises were made.”
In the lawsuit, city attorneys said in 2019 the state took on average 20 days to transfer youths, but many of the 74 juveniles awaiting transfer have been waiting for four to five months. And juveniles waiting to be transferred are not receiving credit toward their sentence.
Unlike adults who are sentenced to a specific incarceration term, juveniles are sentenced to complete rehabilitative programs like anger management, drug or alcohol treatment or other programs. Those can take sometimes three or six months to complete, but the city’s holding facility does not run those programs.
The lawsuit said city officials have been trying for close to three-years to work with the state to address the overcrowding but the issues came to a head in early October when juveniles held in the highest security overpowered staff and forced their way into a common area. Staff said the fight left more than a dozen employees and at least one resident with injuries— some severe.
The lawsuit said staff had to call police for help getting the juveniles back into their units.
The city is asking a judge to mandate that the state take the sentenced juveniles within 20 days and either contract with a private or public facility or open a state-run facility to handle the increase in juveniles. They also ask that the state be mandated to prioritize housing juveniles from overcrowded holding facilities.
WHYY is your source for fact-based, in-depth journalism and information. As a nonprofit organization, we rely on financial support from readers like you. Please give today.