Pa. Sen. Doug Mastriano unlikely to face consequences over newly-released Jan. 6 videos
Several social media accounts that are reviewing videos to try to identify people at the Capitol that day said they identified Mastriano in both videos based on his clothing.
Experts say Sen. Doug Mastriano (R-Adams) is unlikely to face consequences for his actions at the U.S. Capitol on January 6th, when supporters of then-President Donald Trump invaded the building to try to stop Congress from certifying Joe Biden’s election as president.
His involvement is receiving scrutiny as newly released video appears to show him walking through police lines with a crowd of people and near the Capitol steps on the east side of the building. Several social media accounts that are reviewing videos to try to identify people at the Capitol that day said they identified Mastriano in both videos based on the hat, scarf and bag he was wearing.
Here are both videos:
Mastriano released a statement on his Senate website earlier this week reaffirming his attendance at the Rally for Trump and subsequent march, but insists he followed the law in doing so. The state senator criticized the people identifying him in the videos, but did not dispute their findings. Mastriano has not responded to a WITF request for additional comment.
“I followed the directions of the Capitol Police and respected all police lines as I came upon them,” he said. “Even disingenuous internet sleuths know that police lines did shift throughout the course of the day. I followed those lines as they existed.”
That appeared to contradict an earlier statement in which Mastriano, referring to himself and his wife, said “at no point did we enter the Capitol building, walk on the Capitol steps or go beyond police lines.” The GOP lawmaker condemned the day’s violence in that statement.
A video shared by Huffington Post reporter Ryan J. Reilly shows demonstrators pulling metal barricade fencing away from Capitol Police officers and tossing it away moments before a man Reilly identifies as Mastriano walks through the previous police line with a crowd.
“police lines did shift.”
Here’s one of the “shifts” that Sen. Doug Mastriano witnessed from a few feet away. pic.twitter.com/p2O88Utxch
— Ryan J. Reilly (@ryanjreilly) May 25, 2021
It’s not clear whether Mastriano might have broken any laws. The First Amendment generally protects protests, but there’s some grey area if a person crosses police lines or tries to harm anyone. District of Columbia law allows police to set up barricades “for the safety of the demonstrators,” but prohibits their use to strictly prevent a protest.
Pennsylvania state lawmakers can’t be arrested for any views they express in their capacity as legislators in most instances, thanks to what’s called the “Speech and Debate” clause of the state constitution, which mirrors a clause found in the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.
However, Temple University legal professor Laura Little said that doesn’t apply to Mastriano’s rally and demonstration activities.
“Nothing about the facts that have been presented to me show that he acted as a legislator,” Little said. “It appears he was acting as a private citizen.”
Politically, Mastriano has so far faced no public consequence. State Senate Republicans, the Pennsylvania Republican Party, and Adams County Republican Committee haven’t commented on the newly-released footage — despite multiple requests for comments over the last several days.
The Democratic Legislative Campaign Committee has renewed its calls for the state Senate to remove Mastriano from office. But earlier this year, Senate President Pro Tempore Jake Corman (R-Centre) said the Senate wouldn’t take action because Mastriano had assured him he did not take part in any “unlawful activities.”
“Absent facts to the contrary, the Senate has no cause to act,” Corman said in a statement.
Plus, being there on Jan. 6th may actually help Mastriano with some voters if he runs for governor. Penn State Harrisburg public policy and administration professor Dan Mallinson said that’s because some Republicans believe, without evidence, that left-wing agitators caused the violence.
“As long as he wasn’t in the building, but he was there for the protest because that was the right thing to do [in their eyes], then that fits that narrative,” Mallinson said.
The FBI has arrested members of right wing extremist groups like the Proud Boys for allegedly taking part in the insurrection. As of mid-April, police had arrested 45 people from Pennsylvania on charges stemming from the attack. It’s the second highest total of any state in the country, behind only Texas.
Official arrest summaries state several had ties to conservative individuals and groups or made statements saying they support former President Trump. The FBI has cited the work of amateur online groups in charging documents for dozens of suspects.
Mastriano has also courted Trump voters. In the run-up to the Capitol attack, the GOP state senator embraced Trump’s election fraud lies in public statements and during a Senate Majority Policy meeting last November.
“He has drawn himself very close to former President Trump, so I don’t think being at the insurrection and being fairly close affects him with those core supporters,” Mallinson said.
Duquesne University political science chair Dr. Clifford Bob said the incident could help Mastriano prove his conservative bona fides in both a state Senate re-election campaign as well as any potential gubernatorial primary race.
“It’s possible that he could use his presence there to prove that he’s a greater defender of Donald Trump than someone else who wasn’t there,” Bob said.
Get daily updates from WHYY News!
WHYY is your source for fact-based, in-depth journalism and information. As a nonprofit organization, we rely on financial support from readers like you. Please give today.