UIL pulls the plug on PGW agreement

 A Philadelphia Gas Works crew back fills part of Van Pelt Street after replacing aging gas lines in North Philadelphia. (Lindsay Lazarski/WHYY)

A Philadelphia Gas Works crew back fills part of Van Pelt Street after replacing aging gas lines in North Philadelphia. (Lindsay Lazarski/WHYY)

A plan to sell Philadelphia Gas Works to a private company is officially dead.

Because of a lack of action from City Council, UIL Holdings issued a statement saying it had “no choice” but to terminate its offer to buy PGW.

The Nutter administration selected the Connecticut-based company from a list of bidders for the city-owned utility, but after an extensive review, City Council decided against holding a hearing on the proposed deal. Instead, it held hearings about the city’s energy future.

Since the summer, an escape clause in the agreement allowed the UIL to exit without penalty. But it persevered for months, trying to salvage the $1.86 billion deal.

The agreement would have automatically terminated at the end of the year.

In addition to updating PGW’s infrastructure more quickly, Mayor Michael Nutter wanted to use the sale proceeds to replenish the city’s pension fund.

In the wake of the Thursday announcement, Mayor Michael Nutter and City Council President Darrell Clarke issued dueling statements.

“This decision by the Philadelphia City Council is a big mistake and represents a massive failure in leadership for our city and our citizens. It is unfortunate for Philadelphia that City Council could not make a public decision in this important matter following public hearings and an up or down vote,” Nutter said. “Instead, City Council held no hearings and chose a behind-the-scenes decision-making process and no action, thus shutting out the public and denying Philadelphians the opportunity to voice their views.”

Clarke, in turn, placed the blame directly on Nutter’s doorstep.

“Make no mistake, the failure of this deal is not the fault of UIL Holdings,” he said. “The lack of sufficient jobs, consumer and safety protections in this deal are a direct result of the Nutter Administration’s request for proposals, which was limited in scope and issued with no input from City Council.

“Such a shortsighted deal that did not address the concerns of the approving authority, in this case City Council, never had a chance of winning our endorsement. It is a shame that the administration did not make this clear to UIL earlier in the process,” Clarke continued. “This company and its shareholders could have been spared a significant amount of time, money and resources.”

Want a digest of WHYY’s programs, events & stories? Sign up for our weekly newsletter.

It will take 126,000 members this year for great news and programs to thrive. Help us get to 100% of the goal.