Clarke out of Philly mayor’s race — Butkovitz in?

     Philadelphia Council President Darrell Clarke has decided not to run for mayor.

    Philadelphia Council President Darrell Clarke has decided not to run for mayor.

    In what could be a seismic shift in the Philadelphia mayor’s race, City Council President Darrell Clarke yesterday said he’s definitely not seeking the mayor’s office, and City Controller Alan Butkovitz indicated he may jump into the race.


    It’s hardly shocking that Clarke has decided not run. The Democratic mayoral primary is just over four months away, and most thought that if Clarke were going to run, we’d know it by now.

    But he was the consensus choice of city labor leaders and many others, someone who could mount a serious campaign in a hurry if he chose to. Since he hadn’t said one way or the other, no one could rule out the possibility.

    Clarke settled the matter yesterday with a statement saying he loves his job and wants to stay in City Council.

    It took Clarke a long time to reach his decision though, and one potential candidate who found his fence-sitting frustrating was Butkovitz.

    Butkovitz unleashed?

    Butkovitz made it clear months ago he wanted to run for mayor. He engaged an experienced campaign team, but found it hard to raise money, particularly from unions, as long as there was a chance Clarke might run.

    In November, Butkovitz called the whole thing off, said he wasn’t running. But he said yesterday Clarke’s announcement might change his thinking.

    “The phone is ringing off the hook today,” he said. “There’s a large number of people, contributors, activists, calling up and asking me to get into the race. We’re going to have to put a barometer into the water here and figure out what the lay of the land is.”

    One problem, he said, is the city’s campaign finance law, which limits individual contributions, but doesn’t prohibit independent groups from spending whatever they want to help a candidate. And court decisions permit rich candidates to spend as much as they want on their own campaigns.

    “So certain people, if they have money in their own pocket, or if they have billionaire friends, have no limits on their fundraising,” Butkovitz said. “Middle-class people who have experience and ideas have to get through an obstacle course, which involves a lot of organization and a lot of contributors, and generally that takes time.”

    Having lost so much time waiting for Clarke to make up his mind, Butkovitz sees a difficult road ahead.Clarke, by the way, is offering no apologies to Butkovitz for making his decision at his own pace.

    “The reality is that Mr. Butkovitz jumped out early on,” Clarke told me. “He made a decision to run without talking to me, but he did reference the fact that if I ran, he wouldn’t run. He subsequently made a decision that he would no longer run. It had nothing to do with my level of interest.”

    Labor looks for a horse

    Butkovitz says he’ll take a few weeks and think it over.

    Where do the unions go now? I asked Electricians Local 98 business manager John Dougherty, the city’s most politically influential labor leader.

    “I’m staying with the labor movement on the sidelines,” Dougherty told me. “We’re going to wait to see how the field plays out. And you know, the Philadelphia Building Trades, the Philadelphia AFL-CIO, some of the think tanks have all said they’re going, to the best of their ability, to sit down and try to build consensus.”

    A consensus candidate for city labor leaders would be a new and potentially potent development. In the past, unions have divided their support among mayoral candidates. Whether they can agree on someone this time remains to be seen. Dougherty says that could be Butkovitz, could be somebody else.

    If Butkovitz decides not to get in, the current field consists of state Sen. Anthony Williams, former District Attorney Lynne Abraham, and attorney Ken Trujillo. Three others say they plan to run — former Judge Nelson Diaz, communications executive Doug Oliver, and former state Sen. Milton Street.

    Larry Ceisler, the publisher of the website PoliticsPA, said the confirmed exit of Clarke, who is African-American, has a clear beneficiary.

    “I think, for Tony Williams, it’s really going to help his fundraising,” Ceisler said. “The fact is he’s the only major African- American candidate left in the race. In many ways, it’s his election to lose.”

    But Ceisler said Clarke’s decision gives every candidate a bit more room to maneuver, and multi-candidate fields can produce surprising results.

    The filing deadline to enter the race is March 10. The primary is May 19.

    Want a digest of WHYY’s programs, events & stories? Sign up for our weekly newsletter.

    Together we can reach 100% of WHYY’s fiscal year goal