Pa. top court reviewing challenges to releasing clergy abuse report

Attorney General Josh Shapiro is not contesting the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s decision to hold the report as it reviews challenges to its release. (AP Photo/Andrew Harnik)

Attorney General Josh Shapiro is not contesting the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s decision to hold the report as it reviews challenges to its release. (AP Photo/Andrew Harnik)

Days after halting the release of a sweeping grand jury report on child abuse by Pennsylvania Roman Catholic clergy, the commonwealth’s Supreme Court justices have offered more details on their decision.

They say they’re vetting “many” appeals seeking to keep the report secret.

It’s still not clear exactly who is appealing the decision to release the report. But in a new opinion, justices said several people — not dioceses themselves — are challenging it on constitutional grounds.

Not all the individuals named in the report are indicted, but supervising judge Norman Krumenacker has said the report “may be construed as critical of” some of them.

The justices said, in general, the challengers allege their naming “unconstitutionally infringes on their right to reputation and denies them due process.”

The court is staying its release to take more time to review those objections.

The grand jury report is expected to be hundreds of pages long and have significant consequences for the six dioceses is covers.

It would be one of the largest publicly released reports of its kind in the country.

It covers six of the commonwealth’s eight Catholic dioceses. The other two have already received individual reviews.

The state attorney general’s office had said the report could be released by the end of this month. However, Attorney General Josh Shapiro is not contesting justices’ decision to hold the report.

Want a digest of WHYY’s programs, events & stories? Sign up for our weekly newsletter.

It will take 126,000 members this year for great news and programs to thrive. Help us get to 100% of the goal.