Philly area water providers applaud federal rule to replace lead pipes over next decade

Water providers in the Philadelphia region are applauding new federal regulations that require the removal of all lead pipes in the U.S. within 10 years.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency rule, which doesn’t take effect for another three years, comes a decade after children in Flint, Michigan, were exposed to the neurotoxin in their drinking water.

New Jersey implemented a similar deadline three years ago to remove all lead pipes in the state. The new federal rule would help align neighboring Pennsylvania and Delaware.

President Joe Biden announced the new federal rule Tuesday in the swing state of Wisconsin during the final month of a tight presidential campaign. The announcement highlights an issue — safe drinking water — that Kamala Harris has prioritized as vice president and during her presidential campaign. The new rule supplants a looser standard set by former President Donald Trump’s administration that did not include a universal requirement to replace lead pipes.

Biden and Harris believe it’s “a moral imperative” to ensure that everyone has access to clean drinking water, EPA Administrator Michael Regan told reporters Monday. “We know that over 9 million legacy lead pipes continue to deliver water to homes across our country. But the science has been clear for decades: There is no safe level of lead in our drinking water.”

The rule is the strongest overhaul of lead-in-water standards in roughly three decades. Lead, a heavy metal used in pipes, paints, ammunition and many other products, is a neurotoxin that can cause a range of disorders from behavioral problems to brain damage. Lead lowers IQ scores in children, stunts their development and increases blood pressure in adults.

The EPA estimates the stricter standard will prevent up to 900,000 infants from having low birthweight and avoid up to 1,500 premature deaths a year from heart disease.

Environmental groups across the U.S., including in Pennsylvania, say the new rule is a positive step in the right direction.

“This is the most significant step since the Flint water crisis to protect drinking water from lead nationally and here in Pennsylvania,” said Stephanie Wein, a clean water and conservation advocate for environmental group PennEnvironment. “That’s a great takeaway and something to really be excited about.”

The new regulation is stricter than one proposed last fall and requires water systems to ensure that lead concentrations do not exceed an “action level” of 10 parts per billion, down from 15 parts per billion under the current standard. If high lead levels are found, water systems must inform the public about ways to protect their health, including the use of water filters, and take action to reduce lead exposure while concurrently working to replace all lead pipes.

Until lead pipes are replaced, PennEnvironment is calling for legislation that would require school districts in Pennsylvania to replace outdated water fountains with water bottle refilling stations that include filters that remove lead.

Schools in Pennsylvania currently can be exempt from testing lead in drinking water if they discuss the issue of lead in public meetings.

The new EPA rule also implements a national requirement to test for lead in all elementary schools and child-care facilities that rely on public drinking water, and that water providers offer testing to middle and high schools.

Lead pipes often impact low-income urban areas the most. They are most commonly found in older, industrial parts of the country, including major cities such as Philadelphia, Wilmington, Camden and Milwaukee, where Biden will announce the standards on Tuesday.

In Philadelphia, it’s estimated about 25,000 service lines contain at least some lead. According to the Philadelphia Water Department, an estimated one in 20 households are connected to lead service lines. As of February 2023, the city had replaced more than 2,600 lead service lines.

The new rule also revises the way lead amounts are measured, which could significantly expand the number of cities and water systems that are found to have excessive levels of lead, the EPA said.

To help communities comply, the agency is making available an additional $2.6 billion for drinking water infrastructure through the bipartisan infrastructure law. The agency also is awarding $35 million in competitive grants for programs to reduce lead in drinking water.

The 10-year timeframe won’t start for three years, giving water utilities time to prepare. A limited number of cities with large volumes of lead pipes may be given a longer timeframe to meet the new standard.

In a statement, investor-owned utility American Water said it’s committed to removing lead service lines “for the health, safety and peace of mind of our customers.”

“American Water meets water quality lead standards and has been, and will continue, replacing customer-side lead service lines across our footprint in accordance with regulations,” the company said.

Aqua Pennsylvania began replacing lead pipes seven years ago, said Chris Crockett, chief environmental safety and sustainability officer for Essential Utilities, parent company of Aqua. After lead pipe replacement is scheduled, customers are offered a pitcher filter.

“We’re pleased that EPA has finally published this long awaited regulation, and we’re looking forward to working with EPA and our state regulators to getting the lead out and reducing lead for all customers,” he said.

Crockett said he believes the financial support available is adequate to meet the new federal rules, but that it will be a matter of time to determine whether the funding will be enough to support “more challenged communities.”

Officials in New Jersey said the state is receiving $44.1 million in funding to replace lead pipes, of which 49% must be allocated to disadvantaged communities.

“This newly announced funding will help New Jersey communities with the vital task of replacing all lead pipes within the next ten years as we work to ensure that everyone in New Jersey has access to clean, safe drinking water,” New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy said in a statement. “These critical investments in our drinking water infrastructure will help protect our children from lead exposure, create good-paying jobs for New Jerseyans, and ensure a stronger drinking water system for generations to come.”

In a statement, an official for the City of Wilmington, Delaware, said the city is committed to protecting the community from lead. The city has been working to meet federal requirements to identify lead pipes among its inventory, and expects to make its findings public in the coming days.

Lead pipes can corrode and contaminate drinking water; removing them sharply reduces the chance of a crisis. In Flint, a change in the source of the city’s drinking water source more than a decade ago made it more corrosive, spiking lead levels in tap water. Flint was the highest-profile example among numerous cities that have struggled with stubbornly high levels of lead, including Newark, New Jersey, Benton Harbor, Michigan, and Washington, D.C.

The original lead and copper rule for drinking water was enacted by the EPA more than 30 years ago. The rules have significantly reduced lead in tap water but have included loopholes that allowed cities to take little action when lead levels rose too high.

“I think there is very broad support for doing this. Nobody wants to be drinking lead-contaminated tap water or basically sipping their water out of a lead straw, which is what millions of people are doing today,” said Erik Olson, a health and food expert at the nonprofit Natural Resources Defense Council, speaking generally about the EPA’s efforts to replace lead pipes ahead of the official announcement.

Actually getting the lead pipes out of the ground will be an enormous challenge. The infrastructure law approved in 2021 provided $15 billion to help cities replace their lead pipes, but the total cost will be several times higher. The requirement also comes as the Biden administration proposes strict new drinking water standards for forever chemicals called PFAS, or per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances. These standards will also improve public health although at a cost of billions of dollars.

The American Water Works Association, an industry group, said when the proposed rule was announced that it supports EPA’s goals, but warned that costs could be prohibitive.

Another hurdle is finding the lead pipes. Many cities do not have accurate records detailing where they are. Initial pipe inventories are due this month, and many cities have said they don’t know what substances their pipes are made of.