Democrats reject Trump border wall proposal, calling it a ‘non-starter’

President Trump speaks about the partial government shutdown, immigration and border security in the Diplomatic Reception Room of the White House Saturday.
(Alex Brandon/AP)

President Trump speaks about the partial government shutdown, immigration and border security in the Diplomatic Reception Room of the White House Saturday. (Alex Brandon/AP)

Updated at 5:18 p.m. ET

With negotiations over re-opening the government at a standstill, President Trump offered to back temporary protections for some immigrants brought to the country illegally as children, many of whom are now adults, in exchange for funding for a wall on the southern border.

Trump also offered to extend the Temporary Protected Status program that blocks deportation of certain immigrants fleeing civil unrest or natural disasters.

The proposal had multiple components, including requests for:

  • $800 million for urgent humanitarian assistance;
  • $805 million for drug-detection technology to secure ports of entry;
  • 2,750 additional border agents;
  • 75 new immigration judge teams for a court backlog of nearly 900,000 cases;
  • Allow Central American minors to apply for asylum in their home countries;
  • $5.7 billion for strategic deployment of physical barriers or a wall, but not, Trump said, a 2,000-mile concrete structure. He wants to add 230 miles this year and claims the crime rate and drug problem “would be quickly and greatly reduced” … “some say it would be cut in half.”

In exchange for:

  • Three years of legislative relief for some 700,000 recipients of the Obama-era initiative known as Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, which protects some immigrants brought to the U.S. illegally as children from being deported. The Trump administration had moved to end DACA, but the decision was challenged in court and is currently held up in legal proceedings. Trump’s proposal would give an extension of legal status and protection from deportation;
  • Three-year extension of temporary protected status for some 300,000 facing expiration.
  • Trump said these measures would allow three more years of certainty to work on a larger immigration deal.

Even before he spoke, however, the deal appeared to be dead on arrival with Democratic leaders. They insisted Trump needs to open the government before beginning any negotiations over border security or barrier funding.

Before the speech, based on initial reports, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi called Trump’s demands “a compilation of several previously rejected initiatives, each of which is unacceptable.” She added that Trump’s proposal does not “represent a good faith effort to restore certainty to people’s lives.”

Some 800,000 federal workers throughout the country have either been furloughed or made to work without pay. Workers have now missed one paycheck and will miss another if the shutdown is not resolved in the next week. Trump has signed legislation to give back pay to federal workers once the government is reopened.

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell pledged to put Trump’s proposal up for a vote in the Senate this week.

“Everyone has made their point—now it’s time to make a law,” McConnell said in a statement shortly after the speech. “I intend to move to this legislation this week. With bipartisan cooperation, the Senate can send a bill to the House quickly so that they can take action as well. The situation for furloughed employees isn’t getting any brighter and the crisis at the border isn’t improved by show votes. But the president’s plan is a path toward addressing both issues quickly.”

Rep. Mark Meadows, R-N.C., head of the conservative House Freedom Caucus, praised Trump’s move and put the ball in Democrats’ court.

Not everyone in the conservative base was happy with Trump’s proposal. Conservative commentator Ann Coulter called Trump’s move “amnestying millions of illegals.”

During this longest partial government shutdown in U.S. history, Trump has suffered in the polls. Polls have found more people blame Trump than congressional Democrats, and that number is on the rise. An NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist poll also found Trump’s approval rating down to 39 percent and slipping with his base.

Coming out Saturday and making this speech was an attempt by the president to reclaim the narrative and appear to be conciliatory. Democrats indicate the president did not reach out to them before the speech and don’t see what he’s doing, as Pelosi noted, as a good-faith effort at compromise.

Trump’s offer is based, in part, on bipartisan legislation proposed by Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham and Democrat Dick Durbin, known as the BRIDGE Act. The bill would give three years of protections to Dreamers. But before Trump’s speech, Durbin, a member of Senate Democratic leadership, rejected Trump’s use of the bill in this way and called for the government first to be reopened before any negotiations on a border barrier could take place.

“First, President Trump and Senate Majority Leader McConnell must open the government today,” said Durbin, the minority whip in the Senate. “Second, I cannot support the proposed offer as reported and do not believe it can pass the Senate. Third, I am ready to sit down at any time after the government is opened and work to resolve all outstanding issues.”

This is the latest move by the White House in the midst of it’s showdown with Democrats, who have balked at providing the money for construction of a border wall. Democrats contend that Trump’s push for the wall is immoral and that it is an ineffective way to stop illegal crossings.

Trump argues a wall is necessary for national security. He has refused to sign any spending bill without the funding. The president has dug in on wall funding, resulting in a government shutdown beginning in late December. The president had indicated he would sign temporary funding measures to keep the government open, but then he faced a backlash in conservative media over it.

Until now, the White House had said it would be open to negotiating on the amount of money it will accept for a wall, but has been noncommittal about offering other concessions to Democrats.

Almost a year ago, Democrats offered some $25 billion in exchange for a path to citizenship for those almost 700,000 DACA recipients. Democrats say Trump balked at the offer, demanding more after Democrats thought they had a deal.

Democrats have passed several bills out of the House to fund and reopen agencies that are currently shutdown. McConnell has not brought them to the floor of the Senate, deferring instead to the need for negotiations between Trump and Democrats.

Copyright 2019 NPR. To see more, visit

Want a digest of WHYY’s programs, events & stories? Sign up for our weekly newsletter.

It will take 126,000 members this year for great news and programs to thrive. Help us get to 100% of the goal.