Pa. nearly as tough as Texas on violent crime, new analysis finds

    Pennsylvania's punishment rate is the highest in the Northeast

    Pennsylvania's punishment rate is the highest in the Northeast

    Pennsylvania is nearly as harsh as Texas when it comes to punishing violent crimes, according to a new analysis.


    The findings rely on a new formula called the punishment rate, developed by the nonpartisan Pew Charitable Trusts.

    Pennsylvania’s punishment rate is the highest in the Northeast, and higher than traditionally punitive states like Arizona, Missouri, Georgia and Arkansas.

    Bret Bucklen, a director at the state Department of Corrections, took a look at the reports.

    His analysis shows that, if state lawmakers hadn’t toughened punishments over the past five decades, Pennsylvania’s prison population would be nearly cut in half.

    “We could empty out eight of our 26 prisons, reduce by 45 percent — or 22,700 inmates — and we would have the same ratio of prisoners to crime that happens in Pennsylvania, as we did in 1960,” said Bucklen.

    The public should be asking questions, he said.

    “Are we getting what we paid for? Are we responding to crime and having less crime?” he said. “Or are we just basically wastefully spending our taxpayer dollars on prison?”

    The state Department of Corrections, which doesn’t include county prisons, spends about $2 billion a year.

    It’s starting a second phase to reshape its justice system, after kicking off the first phase in 2012.

    The plan is designed to save hundreds of millions of dollars by keeping people out of prison.

    Want a digest of WHYY’s programs, events & stories? Sign up for our weekly newsletter.

    Together we can reach 100% of WHYY’s fiscal year goal