A horror writer’s visit to this Bucks County historic house inspires spooky after-dark tours

Edgar Allan Poe once roamed the halls of Andalusia Historic House. This October, you can retrace his steps while listening to the literary giant’s work.

Listen 1:56
Visitors gather at Andalusia

Visitors gather during the first edition of Andalusia's after-dark tours featuring Edgar Allan Poe stories in 2025. (Courtesy of Andalusia Foundation)

From Delco to Chesco and Montco to Bucks, what about life in Philly’s suburbs do you want WHYY News to cover? Let us know!

A small group of visitors huddles together, braced against the crisp October air on a “dull, dark, and soundless day.”

The fading sun casts shadows across a manicured lawn and glints off the sparkling river that borders the estate. An alarmed chorus ripples through the ranks of geese that traverse the grounds, shattering the eerie silence.

As dusk encroaches, a figure emerges from the doorway of the centuries-old house, beckoning the wary travelers into the “mansion of gloom.” The door creaks ominously as they step inside. They pause. They do not yet know what “shadowy fancies” will leap out from the gilded corners.

No, this is not the start of an Edgar Allan Poe story. But it is a small slice — embellished with quotes from Poe’s famous story, “Fall of the House of Usher” — of what visitors can expect on “A ‘Grotesque’ Tour at Dusk,” hosted by Andalusia Historic House, Gardens & Arboretum this October.

“It is about being spooky, but it’s also about sharing a certain history and sharing aspects of the Andalusia site that are unique and special,” said John Vick, executive director of the Andalusia Foundation, the nonprofit that stewards the National Historic Landmark in Bensalem Township, Bucks County.

It’s the second year the museum is offering the Poe tours, Vick said, which allow visitors to walk through the historic home after dark while being treated to dramatic interpretations of several stories from the writer’s collection, “Tales of the Grotesque and Arabesque.”

The purpose is not just to revel in spooky season — although that is part of the appeal, Vick acknowledged. At the heart of the Poe tours is celebrating the lauded literary figure’s connection to the estate.

A historic stone grotto
A historic stone grotto on the grounds of Andalusia Historic House, Gardens & Arboretum in Bensalem, Bucks County, will play host to the final spooky story performance during its “Poe tours” this October. (Emily Neil/WHYY)

Poe pays a visit to Andalusia

Poe visited Andalusia in the fall of 1840, at the invitation of Nicholas Biddle, its then-proprietor and resident, Vick said. The writer was residing in Philadelphia, where he lived for six years while producing some of his most well-known work, including “The Tell-Tale Heart,” “The Black Cat,” “The Murders in the Rue Morgue” and more.

“Poe, of course, was a great writer, but Nicholas Biddle was a really brilliant literary mind, as well,” Vick said, referring to the prominent Philadelphia financier and editor.

The two men had corresponded, and Poe, who was experiencing financial difficulties, might have visited Biddle to ask for support for an upcoming publication or an introduction to others in Biddle’s social circle, Vick said. The details are lost to time.

“We don’t really know what they talked about, but [Poe] did write a letter afterwards to Nicholas saying it was really wonderful of you to host me at Andalusia,” he said. The confirmation of Poe’s visit to the estate is “exciting” for Andalusia, Vick said, because Biddle typically entertained guests in his Philadelphia home rather than the mansion along the Delaware River.

Poe followed up his visit by sending Biddle a signed first edition of “Tales of the Grotesque and Arabesque.” All of the stories presented on the tours are drawn from that work.

The house’s history and Greek Revival architecture, as well as the writer’s presence in its hallways, help bring the horror stories to life, Vick said.

“I just had fun and let my imagination try to picture Andalusia in the stories of Poe’s book,” he said. “That’s sort of fabricated. Poe was not inspired by Andalusia, but I do think the stories are very much at home here.”

Poe and Biddle could have sat in the library, the very room where Lisa Panzer, an actor and guide at Andalusia, will perform the first of the stories.

“I think that this is probably where they sat,” Vick said. “And if not, they must have at least walked through the house and been in here at some point.”

‘Tricks of the eyes and ears’ at Andalusia provide ‘perfect’ backdrop for Poe’s stories

Panzer’s performance for the dramatic readings of Poe’s work is a new addition to the tours.

The home “create[s] the perfect conditions for the telling of these stories,” she said.

“There’s a sense of otherworldliness of space and sky and spirits and the rustling of leaves,” she said. “Tap tap tapping of tree branches against the facade, drip drip dripping of an old faucet, shadows careening across walls, tick-tock clocks, creaks, and other tricks of the eyes and ears.”

Lisa Panzer smiles
Lisa Panzer, an actor and guide at Andalusia Historic House, is performing dramatic interpretations of several Edgar Allan Poe stories during Andalusia’s “A ‘Grotesque’ Tour at Dusk.” (Emily Neil/WHYY)

Vick curated the program to include stories that evoke Andalusia’s atmosphere, he said, and fit well with the surroundings of the various rooms and buildings featured on the tour.

“One of the stories, for instance, includes a duel, and there’s a family member who died in a duel, and his portrait and a memorial and a locket of his hair are here and have been on view for a long time,” Vick said.

Another tale takes place in a tomb. To evoke that atmosphere, it is recounted in the historic stone grotto that sits at the edge of the property, on the banks of the Delaware River. The building, which is not normally open to the public, “kind of looks like this old Gothic ruin that you would see in a French Romantic painting,” Vick said.

The stories aren’t just all screams and scares, Vick said. The story performed in the stone grotto is “about sort of paying respect and homage to those who have passed and to past generations,” he said — a fitting theme for Andalusia.

“That’s what we try to do by preserving a historic home and the stories of a home like this,” Vick said. “It’s about being respectful and understanding that the past has something to say.”

As for just how much the past makes itself known in the historic home, Vick said former colleagues who worked there “have stories,” but he himself has never experienced anything supernatural on the grounds.

“There’s plenty of occasions for a light at the end of a hallway or a funny shadow to catch your eye and make you jump, and then you look again and you realize it’s all normal,” Vick said. “There’s certainly been times where I’m here after dark by myself, and it does feel a little eerie, but it’s an old house. There’s single-pane glass. Things kind of creak and rattle around. That’s the way it is.”

Andalusia Historic House, Gardens and Arboretum
Andalusia Historic House, Gardens & Arboretum in Bensalem, Bucks County, is hosting after-dark tours this October inspired by Edgar Allan Poe’s connection with the estate. (Emily Neil/WHYY)

The Poe tours, he said, are “a fun opportunity to allow your imagination to take hold of you.”

“I think that’s what’s fun about Halloween and October,” Vick said. “It’s sort of a moment when you let your more rational, logical self take a back seat, and you embrace your imagination, regardless of what’s actually there.”

Plus, viewing the grounds at night has its own aesthetic appeal, Panzer said.

“It’s wonderfully dark here at night. If there’s a moon, there’s a gorgeous silver sheen on the water, and the clouds can take shape,” she said. “The little creaks and taps and whatnot around the house — it’s spooky and fun, and it is definitely different here at night than during the day.”

The tours sold out “immediately” last year, and are nearly sold out for this year’s dates. More information about tickets can be found on the organization’s website.

a tree on the Andalusia Historic House, Gardens and Arboretum grounds
Andalusia Historic House, Gardens & Arboretum in Bensalem, Bucks County, is hosting after-dark tours this October inspired by Edgar Allan Poe’s connection with the estate. (Emily Neil/WHYY)

Saturdays just got more interesting.

WHYY is your source for fact-based, in-depth journalism and information. As a nonprofit organization, we rely on financial support from readers like you. Please give today.

Want a digest of WHYY’s programs, events & stories? Sign up for our weekly newsletter.

Together we can reach 100% of WHYY’s fiscal year goal