Judge Robert Simpson ruling on Pennsylvania’s voter identification law
August 16, 2012
Yesterday, in a highly anticipated decision, Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court Judge Robert Simpson refused to grant an injunction that would have stopped Pennsylvania’s controversial voter identification law. The challenge to the law was brought by voter advocacy groups including theÂ American Civil Liberties Union and theÂ NAACP that said the requirement to present a state-approved ID at the voting booth would prevent more than a million Pennsylvanians from casting their ballots in November. Â Instead, Judge Simpson concluded that â€ťthe photo ID requirement of Act 18 is a reasonable, non- discriminatory, non-severe burden when viewed in the broader context of the widespread use of photo ID in daily life.â€ť Opponents of the law say they will immediately appeal the ruling.Â Weâ€™ll get reaction to the decision from election law expert RICK HASEN,Â WITOLD â€śVICâ€ť J. WALCZAK, the ACLUâ€™s of Pennsylvania Legal Director who argued the case in court, and RONALD RUMAN of the Pennsylvania Department of State, the office primarily responsible for elections oversight and implementation in Pennsylvania.