Health and Science banner

The Shale Game Part 3: Jobs

Tuesday, September 28th, 2010

Pennsylvania’s natural gas rush has environmentalists and residents worried about contaminated drinking water wells, increased truck traffic, exploding well heads and potentially toxic spills. But the counterpoint all along has been jobs, jobs, jobs.

Photo: Business is way up at Lockhart’s Deli according to Don Lockhart (right)

A study funded by the natural gas industry says drilling the Marcellus Shale could bring 100,000 jobs to Pennsylvania.

As part of our series, The Shale Game, WHYY’s Susan Phillips takes a look at how gas drilling is changing the economic landscape upstate.

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

This part of Pennsylvania was primarily farmland and it’s still dotted with dairy farms. It also survives on timbering and blue stone quarries. Manufacturing plants have packed up and moved overseas.

Andy Henry

Andy Henry lives just about 5 miles from the town of Dimock, where some residents were able to set their tap water on fire after poorly constructed natural gas wells leaked methane into their wells.

Sitting on Andy Henry’s porch in Elk Lake, Susquehanna County, surrounded by his wind chime collection, it’s hard to argue against the economic change natural gas is bringing to this part of the state.

Henry: It’s definitely been a lot of jobs, that’s for sure. But I think we’re learning along with everyone else it’s all pretty new to us.

Henry lives just about five miles from the town of Dimock, where some residents are able to set their tap water on fire because poorly constructed natural gas wells leaked methane into their water supply.

Henry: And I know there’s a lot of fear, Dimock has made the national news with the water, there’s a lot of problems there. but from what I’m learning, we’re all learning together what’s actually under us.

About a mile underneath Henry’s home lies what some consider the second largest natural gas deposit in the world. Henry decided to lease his small piece of land for $2,500 an acre plus 16 percent royalties. A well head on his neighbor’s property drills down about 8000 feet and then branches off horizontally — think of it as an underground fountain that uses high-pressured water, sand and chemicals to loosen up the gas.

Henry’s water well sits just 600 feet from the drilling site. He has mixed feelings about how this could affect his tap water.

Not to mention the trucks that rumble down the road past Henry’s house all day long.

Henry: You don’t play in the road…laughter…and today is a quiet day I’ll tell ya…that’s a 17 acre field and there’s about 15 acres tore up there…and they hauled for days…and the water trucks and the sand trucks, it’s like non-stop trucks all day.

Millikan: In truth, although water made the big headlines, and it’s what people are most fearful about the greatest environmental impact to rural Pennsylvania has been trucks.

Henry's water well sits just 600 feet from the drilling site.

Henry's water well sits just 600 feet from the drilling site.

That’s Larry Millikan — who took me on a tour of this part of the Marcellus Shale that sits under Henry’s porch, and all of Susquehanna County. Millikan runs the newly created natural gas technology degree program at Lackawanna College. The first class of 19 students will graduate with an associate’s degree next spring with hopes of getting good paying jobs.

Millikan: We’re seeing an awful lot of jobs from surveyors and engineers to roughnecks and workers on the rigs….and a lot of truck drivers. In fact they can’t hire enough licensed and certified truck drivers to handle the demand for all the work up here. The good thing is there’s a lot of jobs, the bad thing is there’s a lot of trucks.

Millikan says the stone quarries are back to crushing rock for the drill pads, and access roads. Each day, loaders, and trucks are moving thousands of feet of pipe and millions of gallons of water up and down these rural roads.

Millikan is a big advocate of developing the Marcellus Shale — the rock formation that contains natural gas. He says each new drill site brings lots of work.

Susquehanna County drilling rig

Susquehanna County drilling rig.

Millikan: There’s 25 people probably working on this rig, and they make anywhere from $60,000 to $100,000 to $130,000 a year depending on their job and they’re going to have a job as long as they want to do it.

Millikan is a geologist who has worked for the oil and gas industry. Driving in his truck, he says the ecological fears are overblown.

Millikan: This is the biggest thing in Pennsylvania in a century. In the end I think the gas industry will be more beneficial in terms of revenue and economics and jobs and benefits to the state than coal was.

Millikan’s students include a 24-year-old waitress, a laid off draftsman and a few soldiers who recently returned from war. They’re all locals he says, and with their two-year degree they’ll start at $40,000 a year — a significant wage for this area.

Close by in South Montrose, Pennsylvania, “gas men” as they’re called, line up for sandwiches at Lockhart’s Deli and gas station. Owner Don Lockhart says the industry has turned his failing business into a goldmine. The increased traffic has tripled the amount of gasoline he sells and he now checks the paper each day for the price of natural gas.

Lockhart: It was $4.59 this morning..

Lockhart’s business used to depend on two local factories, which closed taking 1,400 jobs away with them.

Lockhart: So the gas coming in here, was like you needing a transfusion, and they come along and give it to ya. And that’s basically what they done for us.

A map on the deli wall is dotted with colored push pins, showing all the different places where the gas men have come from, places like Texas and Arkansas. And although Lockhart is proud to show off the map, it illustrates one of the criticisms held by drilling opponents that many skilled jobs go to workers from out of state.

For Don Lockhart, drilling means a windfall for him and his neighbors.

Don Lockhart with a map he keeps that shows the hometowns of the gas men that frequent his deli.

Don Lockhart with a map he keeps that shows the hometowns of the gas men that frequent his deli.

Lockhart: I have some neighbors of mine that live down the road from me that just got a $178,000 royalty check. Their house needs repair, the barn fell down, they quit farming because they couldn’t make any money at it. One of them went out and bought a $50,000 car and wrote a check for it, God that’s got to be an amazing feeling, I can’t imagine doing that.

The economic benefits are spreading. Hotels are booked months in advance, a local construction company says it has doubled its workforce to keep up with the demand for new pipelines.

But across the border in Wayne County, life is different. Although there’s plenty of gas beneath the Wayne County dairy farms, there’s no new drilling. That’s because the Delaware River Basin Commission has put a temporary moratorium on drilling until it develops its own regulations.

Marybeth Wood is the executive director of Workforce Wayne. She is trying to transform the county’s job market. The number one industry in Wayne is retail, followed by the local hospital, and seasonal tourism.

Wood: There is no one that I know of that wants to have anything happen to the water here to the beauty here. It is a good income generator for the accommodation and hospitality industry…but it pays half of what you would find with the natural gas industry.

Wood carries around a chart that shows how wages in Wayne County are much lower than the wages of other down-river counties in the Delaware River Basin — including Bucks, Montgomery and Philadelphia.

Wood estimates that natural gas drilling will create about 1,200 jobs, making it one of the top employers in a county with a population of just 50,000 people.

Meanwhile, back in Elk Lake, Susquehanna County, Andy Henry still wonders if he and his neighbors did the right thing by leasing the mineral rights and allowing industry to come in hauling their truckloads of water and mud.

Henry: Me I sit here and benefit . It’s a temporary inconvenience, but I’ll be drawing royalties. I just hope that down the road my water is fine, I really do.


  • Nick G says:

    If the shale drilling from 2008 caused methane contamination in Dimock, how to explain this from Penn State discussing methane in water n 2006?
    Methane in water existed before shale: How can it cause methane today?

  • Stephen LaFountain says:

    Hi people think that gas drilling is causing contamination to their drinking water not true.The truth is that methane can suface at any time.When I was a little boy I went to my grandmothers house in new england we were told not to drink the water because of the methane in it,ok to bath.But there was no gas drilling of any kind in that areaand as far as contaminated wells in PA.that methane was there before gas drilling started.Thank You

    • ShaleNo says:

      Are you saying that, because “methane can surface at any time,” drilling cannot cause methane to surface? By that logic, you could say that there’s no such thing as arson because lightning can start a fire at any time. The truth is this: Pennsylvania DEP itself — definitely not opposed to drilling — determined that the methane contaminating wells in Dimock came from deep production layers, and could only have been caused by Cabot’s drilling in the area.

      And here’s another fact: Highly toxic drilling fluids have now appeared in local water wells along with the methane. Did drilling fluids appear naturally in your grandmother’s well?

      • Drill Baby Drill says:

        Yes, drilling can cause methane to surface, but in Dimock “my neighbors got money and I didn’t” caused much more hot air then methane to surface. Nuff said. This area needs jobs and Harrisburg should keep their hands out of the till. Our roads are better now because of the gas companies, our businesses are doing better, the land looks no worse than when the stone quarries tore them up (at least the gas companies put the earth back when they are done!), and there are jobs to be had. God gave us this resource, monitor it, but don’t stop it.

spacer image