Pink ribbon doesn't always mean charity
Wednesday, October 21st, 2009
By: Kerry Grens
kgrens@whyy.org
Each October, breast cancer awareness groups splash pink over anything they can: the Philadelphia skyline, athletes' uniforms, food packages, and more. WHYY's health and science reporter Kerry Grens reports on some who say the pink ribbon may be misleading.
Listen:
Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.
Often, that ubiquitous pink ribbon says: look at me, I'm here to help cure breast cancer. And the cost of whatever it's attached to — say, a t-shirt — will partially go to pay for research.
But not always. The use of the pink ribbon is not regulated. Kasha Ho is the program manager of Breast Cancer Action.
Ho: Just by seeing the pink ribbon on a product you really don't know whether or not any money of your purchase is being donated toward breast cancer research or funding. And many times the money that is donated goes back into marketing the product itself.
Heather Hibshman is the director of Pennsylvania's Breast Cancer Coalition. She advises people to check labels and see where — or if — money is being donated.
Hibshman: Because sometimes it'll say, benefits breast cancer awareness. Well, what does that mean? Who is that going to? What organization does it go to? So yes, consumers have to be diligent about where those dollars end up.
Critics say some companies are exploiting people's suffering to boost sales.
Arnold Baskies is the president elect of the American Cancer Society's eastern division. He says he sympathizes with women who might feel exploited by the consumer side of breast cancer fundraising. But tens of millions of dollars are raised through pink ribbon campaigns.
Baskies: At the end of the day there are more dollars raised and spent for breast cancer in this decade than ever before and the only reason for that is because of the fact that more people are willing to come out and talk about the disease and make it known there is a way to treat it and a way to screen for it.
Hibshman says that, for the most part, pink ribbons have been successful at raising the profile of breast cancer awareness while raising funding for research.
Why not pink ribbons for Universal Health Care and then we'll really see a difference!
Health Care is a right, not a privilege!
Good story. I've always thought it was disingenuous to wear an "awareness ribbon" without doing more. It seems to me that the pink ribbons should be given as prized representations of charitable gifts. This really hits home when I look at the NFL players wearing all manner of pink. Why not ask all NFL players to make a significant donation and allow only those who do to wear the pink as a point of pride.