Yinfo logo

Check out the Y Info channel on DTV 12.3, Comcast 258, FiOS 473
This 24/7 news and information channel features a thought-provoking lineup of regional, national and global programs, including BBC World News, Charlie Rose, Washington Week, Keystone Chronicles and Foreign Exchange. More information »


Philly tries to find its happy zone

Sunday, January 31st, 2010

Philadelphia has long been a place where pitched battles between developers and neighborhoods break out. In this week’s commentary, Chris Satullo reports on a new attempt to broker a peace.


Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Talk to a real estate developer about Philadelphia neighborhoods, and he may get grumpy. He’ll describe those close-knit, feisty communities as the land of NIMBY, the clan of CAVE, the home of BANANA.

N-I-M-B-Y – for Not in My Backyard.

Worse than that is C-A-V-E – Citizens against Virtually Everything.

Even worse is B-A-N-A-N-A – Build Absolutely Nothing Anywhere Near Anything.

For years, the chief battleground between developers and change-averse neighborhoods has been the city’s Zoning Board of Adjustment. At the zoning board each side wins some, loses some – often without any clear rhyme or reason. And that gives rise to suspicions about hidden deals or mob intimidation.

The problems trace back to the creaky old zoning code, which is nearly 50 years old. The city has changed just a bit since then. But few modern projects fit into those ancient rules.

That means the developer needs what’s called a variance, express permission to vary from the written code. That’s where the developer vs. neighborhood battles often erupt.

Philadelphia neighborhoods are places that people care about and fight tenaciously to protect. The average suburbanite can’t imagine how much will, how much wit, how much wallet Philly residents put into protecting their neighborhoods.

In some prized areas, such as Northern Liberties or Mount Airy, residents determined to fend off unwanted projects have developed stunning mastery of law, urban planning and street theater.

Some of their wins are well-earned. But resistance to bad development can easily morph into the Banana Principle, an opposition to all projects, no matter how needed or well-thought out.

Now, the city zoning code is undergoing an overdue rewrite. As part of that, the city asked WHYY, the American Institute of Architects and the Penn Project for Civic Engagement to pull together a series of civic workshops where developers and neighborhood leaders could come together to agree on principles for a new project review process.

The final workshop was last Wednesday. The lion did kind of lie down the lamb. Developers and civic groups did agree on a few core principles. The Arch Street Friends buzzed with ideas on how to make Philadelphia a place where growth happens without squandering the legacies that make the place special.

No code rewrite can eliminate all controversy, all lawsuits. But if the spirit in the room Wednesday can be sustained, Philadelphia will become a far better place both to build and to live.


  • tatil says:

    Lets hope Bayern is going down. Maybe then they will buy some new players. van der Vart maybe

  • arabalar says:

    the real question is “why should i help you” even though you don’t help me? : )http://www.arabacar.com/

  • health says:

    Great Share! I discovered your blog site on google and check a few of your early posts. Continue to keep up the very good operate. I just additional up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Seeking forward to reading more from you later on! health

  • programlar says:

    Just slightly less than an article…more like a tease. I would have loved to have read more but was left with a blurb.

    I wanted some examples of the fight, with ‘street theatre’ etc.

  • Sema Nosmada says:

    Just slightly less than an article…more like a tease. I would have loved to have read more but was left with a blurb.

    I wanted some examples of the fight, with ‘street theatre’ etc.

  • Chris Somers says:

    Love the title ! Hopefully Philly does find its happy zone. I can understand residents not wanting some projects here and there but the bottom line is that the development has helped transform and improve so many wonderful neighborhoods ! With new construction hitting the brakes, there is much less to rebel against. So as a result, that energy went towards the casinos instead of the evil developers. Will look forward to more information that comes out regarding zoning reform and so forth. That happy place is not too far away !


spacer image