It's Our City Home


News and Information Home

 


Hot Topics


Give you thoughts on these current debates:


Philly's "S.S. United States" Ocean Liner May End Up as Scrap Metal »


Philly to bicyclists: Get off the sidewalk »


Is the Philadelphia Parking Authority scaring away tourists? »


 


Mayor's 2010 Budget


Full Coverage »


 


Budget Workshops


Full Coverage »


 


Blogroll


Philly Clout


Heard in City Hall


It's Our Money


More »


 


Mission Statement


It's Our City is a project that uses TV, Radio and Web to promote civic engagement in the Philadelphia region.


 


About Us


Contact Us


Useful Resources


 



How did we get here? City officials explain budget woes to citizens

Friday, February 13th, 2009 at 4:39 pm - by Dan Pohlig. Filed under: Budget, Budget Workshop #1.

Click on the image to watch the latest It's Our City episode

Prior to breaking into small groups and making decisions about how to close the city’s $200 million budget gap for next year, citizens who attended last night’s workshop got a primer in city finances from the folks who deal with them every day. Managing Director Dr. Camille Barnett, Finance Director Rob Dubow, Mayor’s Chief of Staff Clay Armbrister and Budget Director Steve Agostini were questioned by WHYY’s own Chris Satullo for about 20 minutes about the how’s and why’s of a gaping budget deficit. They were joined on the panel by Uri Monson, Executive Director of the Pennsylvania Intergovernmental Cooperation Authority (PICA), the state-mandated agency in charge of overseeing and approving the city’s budget plans.

Satullo began with a simple question: “Where. Did. The. Money. Go?” Dubow answered by explaining how the global economic downturn has affected both Philadelphia’s revenues and expenses like pension liabilities. Other questions included:

1. Why can’t Philly just enact its own stimulus plan and cut taxes like the federal government?

2. Speaking of stimuli, we’re ok now that the Obama plan has been approved, right?

3. What about all of that waste and inefficiency?

4. But you just cut a billion out of the five year plan last November. Why are we doing this again?

5. Are property tax abatements under consideration? (That was an unexpected audience question.)

6. Can we just raise taxes and make up the difference?

And many others. Check out the video above to see the whole session and get a preview of what next week’s sessions will be like. Video running time is about 22 minutes.

The city officials did what they could to explain how the budgeting process works and Monson from PICA talked about how his organization has been working with the city to find other solutions and insure that the revenue projections are correct. (Apparently, a lot of economists got things very wrong back in June. So, if anything, this is their fault. Pitchforks and torches to the nearest economist’s lab, anyone?)

The next workshop is Wednesday, February 18, in Germantown at the Mastery Charter School. Registration starts at 6pm and event begins at 7pm. If last night’s turnout is any indication of what to expect, be sure to get there early.

Coming next… what did I observe as 100 or so who couldn’t fit into the small groups tried to shrink that budget gap? In some ways, the wisdom of crowds prevailed.

2 Responses to How did we get here? City officials explain budget woes to citizens

  1. brendancalling

    “(Apparently, a lot of economists got things very wrong back in June. So, if anything, this is their fault. ”

    NO, it’s the banks’ fault. they’re the ones who created credit default swaps, and SIVs, and all that other crap, essentially chopping mortagges up into a million billion itty bitty pieces and selling them off in a giant ponzi scheme.

    maybe some economists supported this, but not all of them. It’s the banks that got us into this mess, and the state should force them to pay the same BPT as every other business in the city to make up the difference.

  2. Dan Pohlig

    Yikes. Should have put the after the economist thing. If only the city had listened to Nouriel Roubini and Paul Krugman instead of… everyone else.

    But Brendan you do bring a point worth exploring in more depth - the banks and their tax privileges.

Leave a Reply

spacer image